Genre Interpretation
Does the game belong to the metroidvania and/or the magical girls genre? How creative was the implementation of the genres? You can refer to the first section of this jam page.
Enjoyment
Was the game fun? Would you keep playing it? This criteria is highly subjective and mostly based on the feels you got.
Creativity
Was the idea original and creative? If there was worldbuilding and narrative, how well was it implemented? Was the map and level design remarkable? Were the gameplay mechanics innovative?
Sensory
How the game appealed to your eyes and ears, mainly using the visuals and audio. Were those components consistent and did they blend with each other? Atmosphere can also be considered.
Gameplay Polish
How well was the game's concepts put together? Did it have any bugs? Is the difficulty balanced? Does the game give good player feedbacks? Is the user interface intuitive?
Relevance To The Chosen Theme(s)
To what extent did the game follow the theme it settled on? Was it obvious? Was the integration done in a creative or interesting way?